|
The Acquisition of 110 Let's
Fly
by Donna Holaway, ICS # 00029
Past Executive Secretary, CFF
Where do I begin to write about a dream that my
departed husband, Jack Holaway, ICS # 00029, had
so many years ago? Jack was one of the charter
members of the Society, and very interested in the
organization of Comanche owners. He always
remarked "Comanches let the very finest
people fly them."
Jack often wondered what had become of Max
Conrad's famous airplane, the one that set records
which still stand to this day. Time went on, and,
when Jack was elected President of the Society, he
wrote an article in the May 1981 "Comanche
Flyer" in which he said, "Last I heard,
Max Conrad's record setting Comanche was sitting
at Lock Haven, PA with no engine, prop, etc. I
would like ideas of how we might acquire this
airplane, restore it, and display it. Let me know
on this one. It will surely have to be a joint
effort for all of us to get into in terms of time
and money".
The challenge had been offered to the members and
the story of 110 Let's Fly had begun. Upon
researching past issues of the magazine I found
that in August of 1975 Max Conrad was guest
speaker at the Dayton, Ohio Fly-In. He spoke about
his experiences while flying the plane we all
loved and at this time our first President and
founder of the Society, Andy Speer, ICS # 000 2,
presented Max with an honorary membership in the
Comanche Society. Max was issued ICS # 0687 and
the picture was on the cover of the January 1980
"Comanche Flyer".
At this same meeting he brought along his
biography, "Into the Wind", written by
Sally Buegeleisen. I cherish my copy of this book
which is signed, "To Jack & Donna,
"LET'S FLY." This biography can still be
purchased through the Comanche Foundation and I
certainly recommend all members to purchase and
read it, especially since the Comanche Foundation
now owns this historic airplane.
From the fall of 1981 until 1984, Jack served as
President of the Comanche Flyer Foundation.
Because of the interest expressed by the Board of
Directors of the Foundation and others in the
society, it was agreed that we should try to
locate this famous airplane. If this could be
done, we hoped the owner would be interested in
selling it to the Foundation so it could be
preserved for history. Jack was asked to pursue
this challenge.
After many attempts to locate the plane, it was
finally found and belonged to a Mr. Amos Babb. Mr.
Babb was a cousin of Max's and the plane was in
Chicago, Illinois. To further complicate the
negotiation, Mr. Babb had done a great deal of
preliminary work with Howard Gregory of Des Moines
Flying Service towards securing a place for N110LF
in the Smithsonian Institute. However, the
Smithsonian had indicated that N110LF could not be
displayed until space was available so Mr.
Gregory, Jack and Mr. Babb worked toward another
solution.
Jack told of the Comanche Foundation's offer to
buy N110LF. Mr. Gregory suggested we contact Piper
Aircraft and tell them of our plans. Jack was able
to get permission, and Piper sent the files
concerning Max Conrad and Piper Aircraft. These
priceless documents included publicity photos,
letters between Max and Piper, folders for the
record setting flights and much more. Jack turned
over all of these important papers and information
and they now are safely housed with the Foundation
papers.
The project to restore N110LF was gaining
momentum. An article was printed in the October
1986 Flyer with a brief history and a challenge to
the Foundation asking the members of the Society
to spearhead the financing of such a project.
Challenges included purchasing the plane, making
it air worthy, and finding a permanent location to
preserve it for history. It was a complicated
project. Jack and I were fortunate to have Mr.
Babb fly N110LF into Grant, NE while Mr. Babb was
retracing Max Conrad's journey by landing in every
state in the union. Jack looked at the plane and
saw it was indeed in need of Tender Loving Care.
He became more determined to make the effort to
buy N110LF immediately.
After many months of horse trading between Jack
and Mr. Babb, the price was agreed upon. The
Comanche Foundation, which is the charitable arm
of the International Comanche Society, would
purchase the plane and a $5,000.00 down payment
was made. This important event was displayed on
the cover of the November 1987 Flyer when N110LF
was finally sold by Amos Babb. The plane was
delivered to the airport at Gibson City, Illinois
on September 6, 1987. The great day had finally
arrived, but more problems were to follow.
On final approach to the airport, Mr. Babb landed
N110 LF -- but unfortunately --wheels up. New
negotiations immediately followed and the price of
the plane was adjusted considerably because of the
damage. Now this historic airplane belonged to the
Foundation. Mission accomplished. Even in its sad
state of appearance, it was a joyful ending to
many years of negotiations.
With Jack's
mission accomplished, he put the wounded bird
into the capable hands of Dick Schertz, ICS #
02507, for repair, maintenance and restoration.
It was a job well done. However, in a sad sequel
to this saga, Amos Babb was killed in a rented
aircraft while making an ILS approach into
Williamsport, PA. just a week later.
Now with the
loyal support and financial assistance of the
membership of ICS, N110 LF would be restored and
would fly again. Dick Schertz was now in charge
of the restoration of the plane and he will
write Part II of the acquisition story.
PART II
What did it take
to convince large numbers of civilians that
small, light aircraft were reliable enough to
own and use for personal travel and business? It
took Max Conrad, Piper Aircraft, and that great
neat, "bring-em home again" Piper
Comanche N110LF to prove this theory.
Max proved 3
times that N110LF would not fail even with
continuous running of 58½ hours over ocean or
land. People understood that N110LF, picked at
random off the assembly line at Piper's factory
in Lock Haven, PA, was indeed a change from the
days of unreliable engines and aircraft. Now you
could buy these same airplanes and safely use
them like any other mode of transportation.
Finding and
restoring N110 LF was indeed a rather intense
and difficult procedure. Jack Holaway, one time
president of the Comanche Flyer Foundation and
an ardent admirer of Max Conrad, insisted that
this would be possible and indeed should be done
by CFF. Jack located the plane in Chicago, IL.
It was owned at that time by Amos Babb, Max's
cousin. Amos had not maintained the airplane and
it showed.
While landing the
airplane at Gibson City, IL, Amos made a nice
approach but didn't extend the gear before
landing. The airplane floated half way down the
runway because without the gear down there is
not nearly enough drag (I read that somewhere).
The result was the sickening sound of sudden
engine stoppage and a gash in the runway as poor
N110LF skidded to a stop on its belly.
The CRS Flying
Service crew brought a tractor with a loader to
pick up the crippled aircraft. Since he weighed
the least, grandson Jim Noellsch was selected to
climb into the suspended airplane. As
instructed, he turned on the master switch and
placed the gear selector in the down
position.... voila down came the gear minus the
gear doors. (We later determined that this was
number seven in the gear- up landing history of
good old N110LF).
The price of the
airplane had been agreed upon earlier, only that
was without the stipulation of making gear-ups
at delivery. Amos agreed to pay for the damage
and was given a down payment. Now things became
even more complicated. When Amos was
ferried via Jack May to Beardstown, IL, a week
later Amos's death in a rented aircraft threw
the whole acquisition deal into one great big
legal bucket of worms.
Amos's brother, a
lawyer who lived in California, was the executor
of his estate.. He hired a lawyer from Chicago
to oversee the mess and a nephew was the
beneficiary of the airplane. One year later
everyone decided that donating the aircraft to
the Comanche Flyer Foundation was much less
expensive than dealing with Dick Schertz and his
charges to repair the airplane if they didn't
want to donate it.
Now it was
possible to begin work on the airplane in
earnest. "In earnest" meant
scrounging and making do, travel, phone calls,
and trips to the Piper Aircraft Factory in Vero
Beach, FL. It became evident what poor
maintenance had been done on poor N110LF when,
upon removal of the floor boards, we found that
some wing attachment bolts were missing entirely
and those that were in place were loose. All
skin rivet holes were enlarged and had to have
doublers used in order to replace rivets. This
was the second set of wings for this plane.
Without the donation of parts, money and moral
support from all over the country, we could
never have accomplished the restoration.
Jack's
contribution to the society and to the further
growth of this project was short when he had to
undergo a second heart by-pass surgery and
passed away on April 27, 1989. On April 30, 1989
I received a letter from President of ICS, Jim
Fox, saying the executive committee had approved
a Memorial to the Comanche Foundation in Jack's
name.
When Maurice
Feltz, Chairman of the Fund raising Committee of
the Flyer Foundation was asked why a Jack A.
Holaway Memorial Fund? His response was
Jack was not only a good friend, I never knew
anyone who didn't like him. He was one of the
best- respected Presidents we have had. He was a
good President, and he put in his time as ICS
member, Mid States Tribe Chief and ICS Vice
President. After his term was completed, he
still wanted something to do and he became
President of the Flyer Foundation from 1981
through 1984 and then was elected Executive
Director of the Society."
The original idea
for N110LF, Max Conrad's plane, was not Jack's
but if it were not for his pushing and his hard
work we would not have the airplane today.
Although others have worked on this project in
the past two years, there would not be a project
at all if it were not for Jack. Thus, the
Memorial Fund was originated and all money
collected would be designated to be used for the
completion of the N110LF project. An accounting
of this memorial for Jack for N110LF showed
totals of $10,029.00 that was earmarked for
restoration. Over the years, donations from
members, the sale of Australian wine, and
donations from Annual Meeting and donations from
the tribes have enabled this figure to rise to
meet the demands of the final restoration and
upkeep of the plane. Project N110LF would see
completion.
The July-August
1989 Comanche FLYER magazine featured the first
use of color for the magazine and a colored
picture of Comanche N110LF adorned the cover.
This was one of the ideas that Jack and the
staff had for improving our magazine. It took a
lot of planning and extra effort and the late
John Ekman, editor while Jack was Executive
Director, deserved much gratitude for what was a
most appropriate beginning for the job of
restoring this famous airplane.
PART III
The story
continues when the Canadian Tribe of the Society
requested permission for N110LF to be flown to
Edmonton, Canada for the 1990 Annual Meeting of
the Society. I am quoting from an article
written by Mike Keedy, the first President of
the Comanche Foundation. The title of the
article was "110LF Flies to Edmonton".
Since fame is fragile and fleeting, it is not
too surprising that the memory of the Flying
Grandfather, winner of the Harmon Trophy, had
faded fast after Max's death in 1979. At the
1990 ICS convention held in Edmonton, Alberta,
any question as to "Who is Max Conrad?"
was dispelled. For there in the midst of 189
similar Comanches sat the original history-
making N110LF, proudly bearing her achievements
painted on her fuselage (like her big brother
war birds),. She stood fully restored in her
original colors, stealing the spotlight at
Edmonton and adding another first to her already
colorful career.
Museum pieces
command attention and are often awe-inspiring,
but they seldom reveal the amount of toil,
frustration and expense that went into their
acquisition and preparation. So it is with
N110LF.
It has been a
long fourteen years since that small group of
dedicated men sat in Oklahoma City at the 1976
ICS convention discussing the possibility of
restoring this veteran of aviation which
contributed so much to the Comanche Spirit that
flows so strong today. Nobody had any idea where
the airplane was or whether it still existed.
The Flyer Foundation was only formed that year
and there was no such thing as funds to buy a
Comanche, not even a toy one.
It was not until
1986 that the CFF had matured enough to get
serious about N110LF when it was learned that it
indeed was still in one piece and flying. A
committee headed by the late Jack Holaway, who
had been President of both ICS and CFF, was
formed and immediately began raising funds and
opened negotiations with the owner of the
airplane.
The months of
haggling and bartering were almost thwarted when
N110LF on her delivery flight to Gibson City, IL
was landed GEAR UP. After renegotiation the now
downed bird was placed so restoration and
repairs could get under way.
Dick and Rosemary
Schertz, who own CRS Flying Service in Gibsdon
City, were in charge of this massive project,
with the cost of the restoration borne mainly by
the Jack A. Holaway Memorial Fund of CFF,
consisting mostly of monies donated by ICS
members for this purpose.
The big question
now arose, What to do with this valuable piece
of aviation history. The original idea was to
place her in a museum where both the memories of
Max Conrad and this gallant airplane could be
preserved and shared by all.
A display stand
telling of Max Conrad and N110LF's feats would
tell the story.
On N110LF's
journey home, Dick and Rosemary Schertz flew to
Winona, Minnesota, the birth place and home of
Max Conrad. It was there also, while teaching
young people to fly; he coined the motto Let's
Fly that is boldly displayed on the cowl of
N110LF.
In July 1991 the
Foundation announced that N110LF would be flown
to the Annual Meeting to be held in San Antonio,
Texas. Once again Dick Schertz and Rosemary flew
the plane down. The cabin gas tanks were all
installed except one. The pilot's seat which was
also a gas tank was flown down and installed
later as Dick did not want to sit on a gas tank
of aluminum with just minimal padding as Max had
done on his long flights. The reason for the
installation of the tanks was because we felt it
was more realistic to have the airplane shown
and housed in a museum as it was when the
records were made. In looking into the cockpit,
you could see that Max had removed half of the
upholstery and hardware in order to fit the
tanks inside of the cabin. He had also removed
anything and everything he could to reduce
weight. Then he had to build the tanks to the
existing dimensions of the completely exposed
cabin.
The left control
wheel and shaft also had to be removed. At that
time there was no way to have the tanks full of
fuel and reach the emergency gear release
mechanism. With these improvisions made, N110LF
was indeed a special addition to the convention.
One final flight was flying N110LF to her new home
in the honored place of the Liberal Kansas Air
Museum. The journey that had begun years before
was now a reality. True Comanche Spirit had once
again proved that all things are possible to those
who believe.
There are so many
people and institutions that need our special
thanks.
This was one
project that needed Comanche Spirit and so we
thank our members, CRS Flying Service, Dick
Schertz, John Schertz, Employees of University
of Illinois Institute of Aviation Mechanics, who
participated in the often tedious effort to
track down maintenance records and parts needed
to restore the aircraft to prime flying
conditions.
We also send our thanks to Piper Aircraft, Des
Moines Flying Service, our Comanche Tribes for
their contributions, the Australian Tribe for
their wine that was auctioned off at the meetings,
and those members who donated things that could be
auctioned off using all the money to be dedicated
to the restoration of the airplane.
If I have
forgotten anyone, please know that this project
never could have been done without everyone's
contributions.
One final note
taken from the Southwest Times newspaper,
Liberal, KS dated October 6, 1991. A FAMOUS
ACQUISITION AIR MUSEUM LANDS RECORD SETTING
PIPER COMANCHE. The Liberal Air Museum has
landed the world-record setting Piper Comanche
N110LF for indefinite display.
The 1957 plane
was flown to the museum Saturday. It is owned by
the Comanche Flyer Foundation, Inc., the
educational, charitable division of the
International Comanche Society based in Grant,
Nebraska. It's taken three years to get the
Comanche to the Liberal Air Museum, according
Keith Knos, president of the Liberal Air Museum
Foundation.
Based on the
number of calls he's already received about the
addition of the Comanche to the Air Museum, Knos
said There's no doubt it's going to be a big
attraction. The Comanche comes with its own
story, making it a valuable aircraft.
The new N110LF
emblem patch is now available and can be
purchased (see flyer for details). This patch is
a photo emblem's which reproduces in complete
detail a full color aerial shot of N110LF. It
has royal blue binding and red lettering, Let's
FLY-Max Conrad's N110LF. It also displays the
owner, Comanche Flyer Foundation. It is an
outstanding and unique emblem and you'll be
proud to wear it on your jacket or hat.
There are still
expenses that are being incurred such as
insurance and a payment to the museum, so your
contributions are still welcome. Remember to
earmark your donation "Project 110LF".
Together we can say, Thanks for a job well done
and a challenge completed.
|